What’s the Difference Between Sicilian and Grandma Pizza

Pizzas are available in a broad variety of tastes nowadays days. Sicilian and Grandma Pizza are also quite popular among them. In terms of flour management, Sicilian pizza varies from Grandma Pizza. Grandma’s flour doesn’t take long to raise a little in the oven. On the other side, Sicilian flour is left to rise after being placed into a pan, resulting in a light and airy crust.

Since they seem so similar, choosing one over the other can be difficult. But don’t worry, you’ll soon know the difference between Sicilian and Grandma Pizza. Simply read this post to choose the best pizza for your needs and preferences.

Difference between Sicilian and grandma pizza

Specific things make Sicilian, and grandmother pizza differ from one another. These are detailed following.

The history

Grandma and Sicilian pizzas arrived at various times. Grandma pizza gets its name from a home meal made by Old Italian women in her kitchens. This pizza was launched later in New York in the 1960s. Local shops in New York were the first to bring pizzerias into the world. Since then, Grandma Pizza has gained a large fan base.

The history of Sicilian pizza, on the other hand, is different. Even though it is called Sicilian, it is not, in fact, Sicilian. The Sicilian pizza that we are familiar with is not genuine southern Italian cuisine. The Sicilian pizza was introduced in Manhattan’s Little Italy district, and the premiere took place there.

Once Sicilian Pizza came to this region, local pizzerias developed their own distinctive Sicilian Pizza recipes. Thus no two are the same. For many years, Sicilian Pie has been one of the most popular meals at various restaurants and pizzerias around the country.

The crust

It’s easy to see the difference between the two pizzas by comparing their crusts. The dough on grandma’s pizza is substantially thinner than the crust on ordinary pizza compared to Sicilian pizza.

The dough for Grandma’s pizza is stretched out on an olive-oil-coated griddle. Grandma Dough has a significantly shorter rising time than its Sicilian counterpart, resulting in a denser and thinner crust.

On the other hand, Sicilian pizza takes longer to rise, despite being baked in the same pan as grandmother’s pizza and using the same olive oil. The completed pizza will have a fluffier, softer, and thicker crust due to this process.

The Cheese and Sauce Order

When assembling Grandma’s pizza, place the cheese on the crust before adding the sauce. It is a smart way to avoid overcooking the cheese layer. The sauce layer is usually always on top of the cheese on Sicilian pizza.

Since neither style originated in Italy, there is no one-size-fits-all method for stacking Sicilian or Grandma Pizzas. However, the outcome will be almost the same whether you begin with sauce or cheese.


For those unfamiliar with the word, Grandma Slices are thinner and have a stronger garlic flavor. Sicilian pizza is more of a deep-dish variety with a texture similar to focaccia and a sweeter sauce than other kinds.

Why do people call it Grandma Pizza?

Grandma pizza was established in the early twentieth century by immigrants from southern Italy who wanted to make a pizza that could be made at home using simple materials. The pie was dubbed “grandma pizza” since first-generation immigrants in their kitchens usually made it.

How many calories are in a slice of Grandma pizza?

Depending on the toppings, a slice of Grandma’s pizza might have anywhere from 250 to 450 calories. Calories are mainly derived from carbohydrates (47 percent), followed by lipids (35 percent) and protein (17 percent).

If you’re watching your weight, stick to the traditional Grandma pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce, and no need for additional toppings if you want to lose weight.

Is Sicilian pizza healthier than regular?

Sicilian pizza is a rich source of calcium, vitamin A, and iron, despite its high fat and salt content. One slice of pizza provides:

  • Roughly half of the recommended daily calcium intake.
  • 11% of the recommended daily vitamin A intake.
  • 18% of the recommended daily iron intake in one sitting.

What’s the difference between Sicilian and Italian pizza?

The dough for traditional and Sicilian pizza is also somewhat different. The Latter requires extra oil, lard, butter, or shortening. Sicilian pizza has a similar brick-like look and is often baked in a seasoned pan.

Final Verdict

Whether it’s Sicilian or Grandma Pizza, each has its following. Furthermore, each pizza has its own distinct flavor and taste. The most noticeable distinction between a Sicilian and a Grandma pie is the thickness and fluffiness of the former’s crust.

In addition, the crust of Grandma Pizza is crispier than a Sicilian pizza. Whatever the differences are, both pizzas are described in detail above. I hope you can find the slices you desire in consideration of the variances.

Related Resources: