The 10 Best Pizzas in Williamsburg VA [Updated Fall 2024]

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

As the sun dips below the horizon and streetlights flicker on, a tantalizing aroma wafts through the charming streets of Williamsburg, Virginia. It’s an olfactory sonnet of melting cheese, freshly baked dough, and simmering tomato sauce that beckons to both hungry locals and curious visitors alike. This sensory symphony is not mere happenstance; it’s a testament to Williamsburg’s burgeoning pizza scene.

Best Pizza in Williamsburg VA

In this culinary treasure trove, every slice tells a story – some pay homage to generations-old family recipes while others flirt with innovation and bold flavors. Our mission? To embark on a gastronomic journey through 2024 Williamsburg, exploring its pizza landscape one mouth-watering bite at a time.

So, loosen your belts and prepare your taste buds for an epicurean adventure as we unveil the 10 best pizzas in this historic city.

Best Pizza in Williamsburg VA

1. Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano

Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano Pizza

Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano is the go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in Williamsburg, Va. With its delectable thin crust and a myriad of toppings to choose from, this Italian eatery has earned a reputation for serving the best pizza in town.

The chefs at Antonio’s meticulously craft each pizza to perfection, ensuring a flavorful experience with every bite. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a more adventurous option like the Barbecue Chicken, Antonio’s offers a variety of mouthwatering choices to suit every palate.

The restaurant’s cozy and inviting ambiance adds to the overall dining experience, making it the perfect spot for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner. So, if you’re in Williamsburg and craving a slice of heaven, head over to Antonio’s Ristorante Italiano for a truly memorable pizza experience.

2. Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta

Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta in Williamsburg, VA is renowned for its mouthwatering pizzas that are considered some of the best in the area. With a wide variety of toppings and a crispy crust, their pizzas are a delight for pizza lovers.

Whether you prefer classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese or more adventurous combinations, Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta has something for everyone. Their menu also includes a selection of delicious pasta dishes, made with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces. From creamy alfredo to tangy marinara, their pasta dishes are sure to satisfy any craving.

The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta a great place to enjoy a meal with family and friends. Whether you dine in or take out, you can expect excellent service and quality food. Next time you’re in Williamsburg, VA, be sure to stop by Olde Towne Pizza & Pasta for a delicious and satisfying meal that will leave you craving more.

It’s no wonder why locals and visitors alike consider it the best pizza place in town.

3. Sal’s By Victor

Sal’s By Victor is a must-visit pizza place in Williamsburg, VA. With its cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, it offers an unforgettable dining experience. The menu is diverse, catering to all tastes and preferences. From classic margaritas to loaded meat lovers, their pizzas are crafted with the perfect balance of flavors.

Each bite is an explosion of goodness, with the dough cooked to perfection and the toppings fresh and delicious. The ingredients they use are of the highest quality, ensuring that every pizza is a culinary masterpiece. Whether you’re in the mood for a traditional pepperoni or want to try something more gourmet, Sal’s By Victor has the perfect selection for you.

So, next time you find yourself in Williamsburg, VA, make sure to stop by Sal’s By Victor for the best pizza experience in town.

4. Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta

Anna’s Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta is a standout among the best pizza places in Williamsburg, VA. This cozy eatery offers a delectable selection of brick oven pizzas that are sure to please any pizza lover. With a wide variety of toppings to choose from, including all your favorite classics and unique gourmet options, Anna’s ensures there is something for everyone.

The dough is made fresh daily, and the pizzas are cooked to perfection in their brick oven, resulting in a crispy yet chewy crust that is simply irresistible. The quality of the ingredients used is evident in every bite, from the flavorful sauce to the perfectly melted cheese.

Whether you are dining in or taking out, Anna’s provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere that only adds to the enjoyment of their delicious pizza.

5. Mellow Mushroom Williamsburg

Mellow Mushroom is a popular pizza joint in Williamsburg, VA that is known for serving up some of the best pizzas in town. With its funky and vibrant atmosphere, Mellow Mushroom offers a unique dining experience that appeals to both locals and tourists alike.

The menu is extensive, featuring a wide variety of specialty pizzas with creative toppings like truffle oil, caramelized onions, and artichoke hearts. Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and baked to perfection in their stone oven. In addition to their delicious pizzas, Mellow Mushroom also offers a selection of salads, sandwiches, and appetizers.

Whether you’re a meat lover or a vegetarian, there is something for everyone at Mellow Mushroom. So next time you’re in Williamsburg and craving a slice of pizza, be sure to check out Mellow Mushroom for a truly enjoyable dining experience.

5. Sal’s Ristorante Italiano

Sal’s Ristorante Italiano is the go-to place for pizza enthusiasts in Williamsburg, VA. Tucked away in a cozy corner, this restaurant brings authentic Italian flavors to the table. With a mouthwatering array of toppings and a perfect crust that strikes a balance between crispy and chewy, Sal’s pizza is truly a treat for the senses.

From classic Margherita to innovative combinations like BBQ chicken and bacon, their menu offers something for everyone. The skilled chefs at Sal’s use only the finest ingredients, ensuring each slice is bursting with flavor. The pleasant ambiance and friendly staff further enhance the dining experience.

So, whether you are a local resident or visiting Williamsburg, make sure to indulge in Sal’s Ristorante Italiano for a pizza experience that will leave you craving for more.

7. New York Deli & Pizza

New York Deli & Pizza is hands down the best place to get pizza in Williamsburg Va. The restaurant has gained a stellar reputation for its authentic New York-style pies that are made with the freshest ingredients. At New York Deli & Pizza, you can choose from a variety of toppings and crust options to create your perfect pizza.

The crust is always doughy on the inside and perfectly crispy on the outside—a true delight for any pizza lover. The combination of the flavorful sauce, gooey cheese, and generous toppings makes each bite a burst of deliciousness. Whether you prefer classic cheese pizza or unique combinations like BBQ chicken or bacon and pineapple, New York Deli & Pizza has got you covered.

With its friendly staff, cozy ambiance, and mouthwatering pizzas, it is no wonder why locals and visitors alike flock to this pizza haven. If you are in Williamsburg Va and craving pizza, do yourself a favor and head straight to New York Deli & Pizza.

Your taste buds will thank you.

8. Huzzah’s Eatery

Huzzah’s Eatery in Williamsburg, Va is a must-visit for pizza lovers. This hidden gem offers some of the best pizzas in town that will leave your taste buds craving for more. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted with a cozy and inviting atmosphere that sets the stage for a delightful dining experience.

Whether you prefer classic flavors or unique combinations, Huzzah’s Eatery has a wide range of options to satisfy every pizza craving. Their pizzas are crafted with a perfect balance of flavors, crispy crusts, and mouthwatering toppings, making each bite a burst of culinary delight.

The attention to detail in the preparation and presentation of their pizzas is truly remarkable. Combine that with friendly and attentive service, and you have a winning combination. So, the next time you find yourself in Williamsburg, make sure to head over to Huzzah’s Eatery for a pizza experience you won’t soon forget.

9. Blaze Pizza

Located in the heart of Williamsburg, Blaze Pizza is the go-to place for pizza lovers. With its unique concept of build-your-own pizza, Blaze Pizza has quickly become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The restaurant offers a wide range of fresh and high-quality ingredients, allowing customers to customize their pizzas according to their preferences.

From classic toppings like pepperoni and cheese to more adventurous options such as artichokes and arugula, Blaze Pizza has something for everyone. The pizzas are then cooked in a blazing hot oven, resulting in a crispy thin crust with perfectly melted cheese.

Apart from their delicious pizzas, Blaze Pizza also offers a variety of salads and desserts to complement your meal. So, if you’re looking for the best pizza in Williamsburg, look no further than Blaze Pizza.

10. Bellissimo Pizza Cafe

Bellissimo Pizza Cafe in Williamsburg, Va is a hidden gem for pizza lovers. With its authentic Italian flavors and cozy ambiance, this place stands out among the best pizza spots in town. Their hand-tossed crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside, creating an ideal base for their mouthwatering toppings.

From classic Margherita to exotic combinations like prosciutto and arugula, the menu offers a diverse range of options to satisfy every palate. What sets Bellissimo Pizza Cafe apart is its dedication to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, making each bite an explosion of flavors.

The friendly and attentive staff ensures a pleasant dining experience where you can savor every moment. Whether you are a local or a visitor, a trip to Williamsburg is incomplete without trying the delicious pizzas at Bellissimo Pizza Cafe.

FAQs On Best Pizza In Williamsburg Va

What Are The Best Pizza Places In Williamsburg VA?

Williamsburg is home to several top-notch pizza joints. Some of the best include Sal’s by Victor, Anna’s Brick Oven, and Paul’s Delicatezza.

Where Can I Find New York-style Pizza In Williamsburg VA?

There’s nothing quite like a delicious New York-style pizza. To get a slice of the Big Apple in Williamsburg, head over to Krispy Pizza, Luigi’s Italian Restaurant, or Brooklyn Boyz.

What Are Some Gluten-Free Pizza Options In Williamsburg VA?

If you’re looking for gluten-free pizza options in Williamsburg, look no further. Maurizio’s Ristorante Italiano, Blaze Pizza, and Vocelli Pizza offer delicious gluten-free pizza options to cater to your dietary needs.


Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Williamsburg, VA offers an array of delightful pizza joints that will satisfy any craving. From thin-crust delights to loaded deep-dish creations, the best pizza in town doesn’t disappoint. With unique and flavorful toppings, cozy ambiance, and friendly staff, these pizzerias are worth a visit.

Indulge in the delicious flavors that perfectly blend tradition with innovation. So, lace up your shoes and embark on a pizza journey through Williamsburg!

Jayden Malone

 Jayden Malone

Hello! My name is Jayden Malone, and I live at 838 Quincy St, Brooklyn, NY 11221. My love and obsession for pizza, especially homemade, started when I was a young age. I have always dreamt of owning a pizzeria, where everyone can enjoy all kinds of pizza, except mushrooms – lol.

Leave a Comment