The 10 Best Pizzas in Columbia MO [Updated Fall 2024]

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

In the heart of Missouri lies a vibrant city known for its lively college atmosphere, charming downtown, and most importantly, its incredible pizza scene. As we step into 2024, Columbia, MO continues to be a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking the perfect slice. From classic pizzerias that have stood the test of time to innovative new spots pushing the boundaries of flavor, this list showcases the very best pizza establishments that Columbia has to offer.

Best Pizza in Columbia

Whether you’re a local searching for your next go-to spot or a visitor eager to indulge in some delicious pies, this compilation promises to guide you through an unforgettable culinary journey in one of Missouri’s most beloved cities. Prepare to tantalize your taste buds and embark on an exploration of the top 10 must-try pizzas in Columbia as we uncover what makes each establishment truly stand out amidst a sea of cheesy competition.

Best Pizza in Columbia MO

1. Shakespeare’s Pizza

 Shakespeare’s Pizza

Shakespeare’s Pizza is a renowned establishment in Columbia, MO, known for serving the best pizza in town. With its crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings, this pizzeria has become a local favorite. Whether you’re a fan of the classic cheese pizza or prefer indulging in specialty options like Margherita or Meat Lovers, Shakespeare’s has something for everyone.

The quality of their ingredients and attention to detail in every pizza they make sets them apart from other pizzerias in town. Not only does Shakespeare’s deliver on taste, but they also offer a cozy and inviting atmosphere for diners to enjoy their meal.

It’s no wonder why Shakespeare’s Pizza consistently ranks among the top spots for pizza lovers in Columbia, Mo. So, the next time you’re in town and craving a slice of pizza, look no further than Shakespeare’s!

2. G & D Pizzaria

G & D Pizzaria is a hidden gem when it comes to finding the best pizza in Columbia, MO. Tucked away in a cozy corner, this family-owned restaurant serves up mouthwatering pizzas that will leave you craving for more. With their wide range of delicious toppings and homemade crust, you can customize your pizza just the way you like it.

The quality and freshness of their ingredients are evident in every bite, making G & D Pizzaria a favorite among locals. Whether you prefer classic flavors or want to try something unique, their menu has something for everyone. From their crispy thin crust to their cheesy deep-dish options, each pizza is made with love and attention to detail.

Next time you’re in the mood for a perfect slice, head to G & D Pizzaria for an unforgettable experience.

3. Shakespeare’s Pizza South

Shakespeare’s Pizza South is known for serving the best pizza in Columbia, Mo. With their delicious and unique pizza creations, it’s no wonder they have become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy on the inside, providing the ideal base for their mouth-watering toppings.

Whether you’re a fan of classic pepperoni, a meat lover, or prefer a vegetarian option, Shakespeare’s has something for everyone. Not only is the pizza exceptional, but the atmosphere at the South location is also inviting and cozy, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a slice or two with family and friends.

If you’re looking for the best pizza in Columbia, look no further than Shakespeare’s Pizza South.

4. Shakespeare’s Pizza West

Located in Columbia, Missouri, Shakespeare’s Pizza West is considered one of the best pizza places in town. With its casual atmosphere and delicious pies, it’s a popular spot for both locals and visitors alike. The menu offers a variety of options, including traditional favorites like pepperoni and sausage as well as unique creations like the Shakespeare’s Special with mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives.

The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is perfectly melted. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch or a late-night snack, Shakespeare’s Pizza West is sure to satisfy your pizza cravings. So next time you’re in Columbia, be sure to stop by and experience the taste of their mouthwatering pies.

5. Gumby’s Pizza

Gumby’s Pizza is undeniably one of the best pizza places in Columbia, Mo. With its mouth-watering flavors and top-notch quality, it has captured the hearts (and taste buds) of locals and visitors alike. What sets Gumby’s Pizza apart is its commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, handcrafted dough, and a wide variety of toppings.

Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or adventurous combinations like the Pepperoni Extreme or Veggie Delight, Gumby’s Pizza has something to satisfy every craving. Its friendly and efficient staff ensures that your pizza is prepared to perfection, delivering a delightful experience with every bite.

If you’re in Columbia, MO, and craving a slice of heaven, head over to Gumby’s Pizza for a truly memorable dining experience.

6. Your Pie

Your Pie is undoubtedly one of the top contenders for the title of the best pizza in Columbia MO. This popular pizzeria has gained a loyal customer base for its mouthwatering pies that cater to all taste buds. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a unique custom creation, Your Pie offers a wide range of toppings and sauces to satisfy every craving.

But what sets this place apart is their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients, making each slice a burst of flavor. The friendly and efficient staff ensure quick service, perfect for a quick bite or a casual meal with friends.

With its inviting atmosphere and delectable pizzas, Your Pie is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Columbia MO.

7. Tony’s Pizza Palace

Tony’s Pizza Palace, located in Columbia, Missouri, is a haven for pizza enthusiasts. With its inviting atmosphere and mouthwatering menu, it undoubtedly tops the list of the best pizza joints in town. Satisfying the cravings of locals and visitors alike, Tony’s offers a delectable selection of pizzas with a perfect crust, rich tomato sauce, and a generous amount of toppings.

From classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese to unique combinations such as barbecue chicken and bacon, there is something to please every palate. The pizzeria’s dedication to quality is evident in its use of fresh ingredients and its commitment to making every pizza a culinary masterpiece.

Whether you prefer thin crust or deep dish, Tony’s Pizza Palace is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in Columbia, Mo.

8. Pizza Tree

Located in downtown Columbia, Pizza Tree is a must-visit pizzeria for pizza lovers. With its funky atmosphere and delicious pizza creations, it has gained a reputation as one of the best pizza spots in town. The menu at Pizza Tree offers a wide selection of unique and mouthwatering pizzas, ranging from classic flavors to creative combinations.

Each pizza is made using fresh ingredients and a perfectly baked crust that is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Whether you prefer a traditional pepperoni pizza or want to try something more adventurous like the Goat Cheese Honey or the Thai Pie, Pizza Tree has something for everyone.

In addition to their fantastic pizza, they also offer a variety of salads and sides to complement your meal. So the next time you’re craving pizza in Columbia, make sure to stop by Pizza Tree for a truly satisfying experience.

9. Mod Pizza

MOD Pizza is one of the best places to satisfy your pizza cravings in Columbia Mo. With a wide variety of toppings and a unique “Build Your Own Pizza” concept, MOD Pizza ensures that every customer gets exactly what they want.

The open-kitchen layout allows you to watch as your pizza is being made, adding a fun and interactive element to your dining experience. The ingredients are fresh and of high quality, resulting in a delicious and flavorful pizza. MOD Pizza’s friendly and efficient staff delivers exceptional customer service, making sure that you have a memorable visit.

Whether you go for a classic Margherita or create your own masterpiece, MOD Pizza never fails to impress. So if you’re in Columbia Mo and looking for the best pizza in town, make sure to stop by MOD Pizza for a truly satisfying dining experience.

10. Crushed Red

Crushed Red is a must-visit pizza place in Columbia, Mo. Known for its fresh and healthy ingredients, this restaurant stands out among the competition. With a focus on using organic and locally sourced produce, Crushed Red provides customers with a guilt-free dining experience.

The wood-fired pizzas are cooked to perfection, resulting in a crispy crust and delicious toppings. Whether you’re a meat lover or prefer a vegetarian option, Crushed Red has something for everyone. The menu offers a wide variety of toppings, including artisan cheeses, premium meats, and a selection of flavorful sauces.

Apart from the delectable pizzas, Crushed Red also offers delicious salads and homemade soups, making it a great option for those who want a lighter meal. If you’re in Columbia, Mo, be sure to stop by Crushed Red and indulge in their mouth-watering pizzas.

FAQs On Best Pizza In Columbia MO

What Are The Must-try Pizza Toppings In Columbia MO?

Some of the must-try pizza toppings in Columbia Mo include savory pepperoni, gooey mozzarella cheese, and fresh basil leaves.

How Are The Pizzas In Columbia Mo Different From The Rest?

Pizzas in Columbia Mo are different from the rest due to the use of locally sourced ingredients, unique flavor combinations, and artistry in crafting each pie.

Where Can I Find Gluten-Free Pizza Options In Columbia MO?

Several restaurants in Columbia Mo offer gluten-free pizza options, such as Shakespeare’s Pizza, XYZ Pizzeria, and City Slices.


To wrap up, from wood-fired crusts to mouthwatering toppings, Columbia, MO is home to some of the most delectable pizza joints. With a wide variety of flavors and styles, these establishments truly cater to every pizza lover’s cravings. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, be sure to indulge in the city’s best pizza hotspots.

Get ready to embark on a flavorful journey that will leave you craving more.

Jayden Malone

 Jayden Malone

Hello! My name is Jayden Malone, and I live at 838 Quincy St, Brooklyn, NY 11221. My love and obsession for pizza, especially homemade, started when I was a young age. I have always dreamt of owning a pizzeria, where everyone can enjoy all kinds of pizza, except mushrooms – lol.