The year is 2024 and Bethany Beach, the jewel of Delaware’s coastline, has firmly established itself as a veritable pizza paradise. Perched on the Atlantic coast, this sun-soaked haven not only offers miles of sandy beaches and azure waves but also boasts an array of pizzerias that can easily compete with those in New York or Naples.
In this gastronomic guide, we whisk you away on a mouthwatering journey through the ten best pizzerias in Bethany Beach that have been tirelessly perfecting their pies. Expect to be tantalized by everything from traditional thin-crust beauties oozing with mozzarella to innovative culinary masterpieces topped with local seafood. Read on if you’re ready for a slice of the action!
Best Pizza in Bethany Beach
1. Pino’s Pizza
- 8101 Coastal Hwy, Ocean City, MD 21842-2971
- 4.6 miles from Ocean City Beach
- Website
- +1 410-723-4000
Tucked away in the heart of Bethany Beach lies Pino’s Pizza, a gastronomic gem that locals and visitors alike rave about. The secret to their mouthwatering pies lies in the homemade dough, expertly kneaded and left to rise to perfection, ensuring a flawless crust every time.
Fresh ingredients top these bases, with a delectable array of cheeses melting into the rich, robust sauce, delivering a flavor that dances across your taste buds. Whether it’s the classic Margherita that entices you or the adventurous specialty pizzas adorned with unique toppings, Pino’s commitment to quality shines through in every bite.
This pizzeria’s delightful offerings not only cater to traditionalists but also to those with inventive palates, ensuring that each visit is as memorable as the last.
2. Trattoria Lombardi’s Rstrnt
Trattoria Lombardi’s Restaurant holds a special place on the culinary map of Bethany Beach for pizza aficionados. A slice of their hand-tossed, stone-baked pizza transports you to a quaint Italian village with its authentic flavors. Each pie is a masterpiece, boasting a perfect blend of tangy tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a selection of gourmet toppings.
The ambiance of the restaurant, paired with the aroma of herbs and oven-fresh pizzas, creates an unforgettable dining experience. Visitors looking to satisfy their cravings for traditional Italian cuisine will find Trattoria Lombardi’s to be a delightful spot that stands out for its dedication to quality and taste.
3. Pomodoro Pizzeria
Discovering the perfect slice of pizza can often lead to endless culinary quests, but for those near Bethany Beach, the search may just end at Pomodoro Pizzeria. Renowned for its authentic flavors and traditional cooking methods, this gem serves up a pizza that is both mouthwatering and memorable.
The crust, hand-tossed and baked to perfection, provides the ideal foundation for the rich, zesty tomato sauce and a generous blend of high-quality cheeses. Toppings are fresh, locally sourced whenever possible, and carefully chosen to complement the dish, ensuring every bite is laden with taste and texture.
Fans of Italy’s signature dish will appreciate the attention to detail and the cozy ambiance Pomodoro Pizzeria offers, making it a must-visit for anyone craving an exceptional pizza experience.
4. Albertino’s
To discover a slice of heaven in Bethany Beach, make a stop at Albertino’s, a gem that locals and tourists adore. Their hand-tossed crust and secret blend of cheeses create a symphony in your mouth with each bite. The chefs masterfully balance the flavors of the homemade sauce and the fresh, locally sourced toppings.
Notorious for their generous portions, Albertino’s ensures no one leaves without their cravings fully satisfied. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or venturous with a spicy pepperoni explosion, this spot caters to all pizza aficionados. Nestled in the heart of the beach town, this eatery is not just about satisfying hunger; it’s about creating memories over a perfect pizza pie.
5. Pie
For those in pursuit of the quintessential slice, Pie in Bethany Beach serves as a delightful stop. Their handcrafted pizzas boast a perfect balance between crispy crusts and succulent toppings, which are sourced locally to ensure freshness and support local farmers.
The menu presents a unique twist on classic flavors, tantalizing the taste buds of both traditional pizza lovers and gourmet enthusiasts. From the robust marinara to the stringy, melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella, each pie is a testament to the culinary dedication of the pizzaiolos.
Don’t miss their signature wood-fired pizzas, which have a smoky undertone that will leave you craving more. Diners rave about the cozy ambiance, making it an ideal spot for a casual dinner or a celebratory feast with friends and family.
6. Mancini’s Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant
Tucked away in the heart of Bethany Beach, Mancini’s Brick Oven Pizzeria & Restaurant serves up a delightful array of gourmet pizzas that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. With their signature brick oven, Mancini’s crafts crispy, airy crusts that perfectly complement the rich, savory toppings.
Each pizza is a masterpiece of flavor, featuring the freshest local ingredients and a blend of aromatic herbs and spices. Whether you’re a fan of classic combinations or looking to indulge in a more adventurous specialty pie, Mancini’s promises an unforgettable dining experience that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more.
This gem exemplifies culinary craftsmanship, solidifying its reputation as a top destination for pizza aficionados in Bethany Beach.
7. Surf’s Edge Deli And Pizzeria
Tucked away in the heart of Bethany Beach, Surf’s Edge Deli and Pizzeria earns its reputation for mouthwatering pizza with a local twist. This charming eatery prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients, ensuring every slice is bursting with flavor.
Whether you’re craving a classic margherita or feeling adventurous with a surf and turf topping combo, their diverse menu caters to all palates. Regulars rave about the delectable crust that boasts the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, a testament to the pizzeria’s commitment to pizza perfection.
Next time you find yourself along the sandy shores of Bethany, be sure to stop by Surf’s Edge for a pizza experience that’s as memorable as the beach views.
8. Ponzetti’s Pizza
Ponzetti’s Pizza stands as a testament to traditional flavors that consistently draw locals and tourists alike. This longstanding establishment prides itself on crafting pizzas with a perfect blend of melted cheese, robust tomato sauce, and fresh, high-quality toppings. Upon entering, the aroma of baking dough wafts through the air, tantalizing the senses and promising a delightful experience.
Whether it’s the crowd-pleasing pepperoni, the veggie-packed garden delight, or a custom creation, every pie exudes a homemade essence. Nestled in the heart of Bethany Beach, Ponzetti’s offers not just a meal, but a slice of community warmth in every bite, making it an essential stop for anyone craving an authentic pizza experience.
9. Grotto Pizza
Nestled in the heart of Bethany Beach, Grotto Pizza stands as a culinary mainstay, enticing both locals and tourists alike with its unique blend of cheeses and secret sauce. With a reputation for serving delightfully savory slices, this pizzeria is a must-visit destination for anyone craving an authentic taste of the town.
The ambiance harks back to a traditional Italian eatery, where every meal is a celebration of flavor and community. Their signature pies are crafted with care, ensuring that each bite provides a perfect balance of toppings, cheese, and crust. Grotto Pizza’s commitment to quality has solidified its position among the top venues for a memorable pizza experience.
10. Squarz Pizza And Restaurant
- 12825 Coastal Hwy Montego Bay Shopping Center, Ocean City, MD 21842-4716
- Website
- +1 410-250-4444
Nestled in the heart of Bethany Beach, Squarz Pizza and Restaurant is a culinary gem that serves up some of the most delightful and memorable pizza experiences. Their secret lies in the unique combination of fresh, locally sourced ingredients and a passion for traditional pizza-making techniques.
At Squarz, each slice speaks volumes about the care and creativity invested in its creation. The crust, handcrafted to perfection, boasts a perfect chew and a gentle crunch that are the hallmarks of a master pizza maker’s skill. This establishment doesn’t just make pizza; they craft a sensorial journey that begins with the aroma of baked dough and ends with a satisfied palate.
For both locals and tourists alike, Squarz has become synonymous with quality, firmly establishing itself as a must-visit spot on the Bethany Beach culinary map.
FAQs For Best Pizza In Bethany Beach
Bethany Beach pizza is renowned for its fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and a distinct blend of spices that cater to seaside palettes, providing a unique flavor profile unmatched in the area.
The best pizza in Bethany Beach can be found at family-owned pizzerias that prioritize traditional baking methods and use stone ovens, which infuse a rustic, authentic taste into every slice.
Yes, several eateries in Bethany Beach offer delicious gluten-free pizza options, ensuring those with dietary restrictions can still enjoy the local flavors without compromise.
Conclusion
Embarking on a quest for the ultimate slice in Bethany Beach has never been more satisfying. From family-owned joints to gourmet pizzerias, the options capture the essence of top-tier pizza. Remember, these spots aren’t just eateries; they’re slices of local flavor waiting to be savored.
Next time your cravings hit, let Bethany’s best guide your taste buds to pizza paradise.